Andrew Purdum

Offers

How to turn expertise you take for granted into a sellable offer

Flat editorial illustration: one red-orange block pulled from a stack of black blocks, set beside a low wall.

Short answerTo turn expertise into an offer, start with the problem it removes, not the knowledge itself. Pick one type of person at one point in their progress, name the first obstacle they can’t get past, and package just enough of what you know to get them past it. Name it after the outcome, price it as an easy first yes, and save the deeper expertise for what they buy next.

People who are good at something usually can’t see what they know. To them it’s just how you do it. Ask them what they’d sell and they describe a giant course with everything in it, because everything in it feels equally obvious.

I’ve been on both sides of this. For a while, one of the things that sold best for me was a single ad, written for someone for about a hundred bucks. I was writing somewhere between five and 15 ads a day at that point, so one more ad felt like nothing. To the person buying it, it was the one thing they couldn’t do themselves. And a lot of the time they’d come back and ask if I could just do the whole thing for them.

That’s the pattern. The skill you take for granted is somebody else’s wall. The job is to find the wall and sell the way over it. Here’s how I’d turn expertise into an offer, in order.

Step one: get it out of your head by explaining it out loud

You can’t package what you can’t see, and you can’t see it by staring at a blank doc. You see it when you explain it to someone who has the problem.

When I build an offer with a client, I start with what I call the core principles and the core philosophy. The principles are the handful of things you believe about the problem that most people in your field get wrong. The philosophy is the big idea that holds them together. Messaging comes out of that, then marketing, then the ads.

The way I pull those out is mostly listening. I record the call, and then I listen to it again later, because every time I re-listen to one of those conversations I catch another principle I missed live. A lot of the good stuff shows up on a walk afterwards, too.

So do the same thing to yourself. Get someone to ask you about the problem for twenty minutes (a client, a friend, anybody who will push back) and record it. Then read the transcript and mark every place where you said some version of “most people think X, but actually Y.” Those lines are your principles. You’ll be surprised how many there are.

Step two: pick one person at one moment

This is where most attempts to turn expertise into an offer go wrong. You know the whole road from start to finish, so you try to sell the whole road.

Everybody lives on a timeline, from the day the problem starts to the day it’s solved. Every day on that line is a slightly different buyer with different worries. If you write to “anyone who wants to get better at this,” you’re throwing a dart at the whole line and connecting with nobody.

My default is someone who is actively in the problem, early to middle, who hasn’t picked a solution yet. Those people are easier to move because they haven’t decided how it gets fixed.

Then name the first obstacle that person hits. Not the fifth. A small front-end product that promises the entire trip isn’t believable, and people can feel that. Getting them past the first wall is believable. If you want the longer version of this idea, I wrote about aiming an offer at the wrong moment.

Step three: write the result in their words, not your curriculum

Experts describe what’s inside. Buyers only care about what’s on the other side.

People buy outcomes and transformations. They don’t buy what it does. They want to become someone, and your offer is the thing that gets them there. So instead of “eight modules on X,” write down what their Tuesday looks like after it works. What stopped being a problem, what they can do now that they couldn’t, what they get to stop worrying about.

If you find yourself writing features, go back to the transcript from step one and look for how the person described the problem in their own words. Use those.

Step four: find what’s stopping them from buying it

I don’t really believe in objections. An objection is just an unmet constraint, a limitation they’ll run into or a concern they already have.

I sort constraints into five buckets: values, beliefs, experiences, identity and resources. Someone who values doing things quietly and privately. Someone who believes the problem is their fault. Someone who’s bought two courses that didn’t work. Someone who doesn’t see themselves as “that kind of person.” Someone with twenty minutes a day and not much money.

Your expertise already knows how to handle most of these, you just handle them one client at a time. Write them into the offer instead. The move I use most is to agree with what’s true in their experience first (“you’re right, that’s exactly what happens”) and then show why this is built for that. I go through the whole thing in how to map the five constraints.

Step five: package it small, name it, and say it in one breath

The first time you turn expertise into an offer for cold traffic, I like a short introductory program somewhere around $17 to $27. Low enough to be an easy yes, high enough that you’re getting buyers and not freebie collectors. It could be a short training, a guide, a template, a recorded workshop. The format matters less than whether it gets them over that first wall.

Name it after the outcome, or call it the something Method. Short, catchy, and it should tell them what they’re getting or how it works.

Then explain it simply and plainly. No jargon. This is where experts fight me the most, because simple feels like it undersells them. I had a coach I was building a funnel for worry that her approach sounded boring. There’s nothing boring about simplicity. People pay for simplicity all the time.

The test I use: if you can’t say what it is, who it’s for and what it gets them in one to three sentences, the offer isn’t dialed in yet. Keep cutting until you can.

Where the rest of what you know goes

When you turn expertise into an offer, you’ll feel like you’re leaving most of it on the table. You are, on purpose.

The front end exists to get someone in the door as a customer. The deeper method, the one-on-one work, the done-for-you version, that’s what they buy after they’ve had a win with you. That’s where the real money usually is anyway. Those hundred-dollar ads turned into people asking me to run everything, and they only asked because the small thing worked first.

Just make sure the small thing solves the first problem without solving the whole problem, or you’ll have nothing left to sell them. There’s a whole piece on building a front end that doesn’t cannibalize your backend if that’s the part worrying you.

What to do this week

Book twenty minutes with someone who has the problem you solve and record the conversation. Pull out every “most people think X, but actually Y” line. Then write one sentence: this helps [one specific person] get past [the first obstacle] so they can [the result, in their words]. If it takes more than three sentences, you’re not done yet, and that’s the week’s work.

How do I know if my expertise is worth paying for?

Look at what people already ask you for help with, and what they keep getting stuck on without you. If a specific group has a painful problem, it touches other parts of their life, and your way of handling it is different from what they’ve already tried, it’s worth paying for. The hard part is usually packaging it, not whether it’s valuable.

What should I charge for my first offer?

For a first offer sold to cold traffic, I like an introductory product around $17 to $27. It’s low enough to be an easy yes and high enough to attract real buyers rather than people collecting free stuff. Higher-priced work, like coaching or done-for-you, usually sells better to people who’ve already bought something small from you.

Should I build a full course or something smaller first?

Something smaller. A full course tries to cover the whole path, which is harder to believe and harder to finish. A focused product that gets one type of person past their first obstacle is easier to sell, easier to deliver, and gives you a customer you can offer the bigger thing to later.

P.S. The part of your work that feels too easy to charge for is usually the part other people can’t do. That’s the one to package first.

Andrew Purdum

Buying traffic since 2014, north of $10M in managed ad spend. Writes about what actually moved the numbers, including the expensive mistakes. Work with me →

More on offers

All 12 →

Work with Andrew

Most accounts don't need more traffic. They need someone to find the leak.

If you're spending real money on ads and can't tell which part is failing — the creative, the offer, or the page — that's a diagnosable problem, and it's the one I'm best at.